Fraud Blocker Root Grapple vs Rake Grapple for Skid Steers | Yard Patriots
Skip to content
Root Grapple vs Rake Grapple

Root Grapple vs Rake Grapple: Which One Fits Your Skid Steer?

You've got logs to carry, brush to clean up, and roots scattered across ground you're trying to reclaim. A grapple would make the job easier, but which style should you buy?

Root grapple vs rake grapple comes down to the work you do most. Start with long supporting lower tines for carrying bulky brush and uneven logs. Start with a short, more vertical rake profile for gathering loose surface debris. For small-rock collection or keeping fines contained, compare close-tine rock grapples and solid-floor grapple buckets instead.

Both root grapples and rake grapples can handle brush, logs, and roots. The difference is how conveniently they gather, support, and clamp those loads.

Root Grapple or Rake Grapple? Start With the Job

Carry Bulky Brush and Uneven Logs

Start With: Long-bottom root grapple; independent lids for uneven bundles.

Main Tradeoff: Long tines can interfere with repeated surface raking.

Gather Loose Surface Roots and Branches

Start With: Short, more vertical rake or clamshell.

Main Tradeoff: Less lower support for irregular bundles.

Collect Smaller Rocks Repeatedly

Start With: Close-tine rock or skeleton grapple.

Main Tradeoff: More soil and clod retention; check actual gaps.

Keep Dirt, Chips, and Fines Contained

Start With: Solid-floor grapple bucket.

Main Tradeoff: Carries soil you might want to leave behind.

Skid steer contractor PTSolutions offered a useful explanation in a 2016 LawnSite discussion:

“If you are picking up a lot of logs and branches of differing sizes then you want a long bottom tine style with individual grapples.”

PTSolutions, 2016, LawnSite discussion.

He used a long-bottom grapple for tree work but acknowledged it could still perform occasional careful raking. The deciding factor was which task he performed most often.

What Is the Difference Between a Root Grapple and a Rake Grapple?

Root grapple vs rake grapple comparison showing long supporting lower tines, short vertical rake tines, upper clamps, and material handling differences

Root grapple, root rake grapple, grapple rake, brush grapple, and grapple claw are terms manufacturers sometimes use for overlapping designs. There's no universal naming system that guarantees one attachment has a particular tine arrangement.

Instead, compare the actual geometry.

Long-Bottom Root Grapple

Storm skid steer root grapple showing extended lower tines that support bulky loads

Short-Bottom Rake Grapple

Storm 48 inch rake grapple showing short curved lower tines and a full-width upper clamp

Long Lower Tines Support Material While Carrying

A long-bottom root grapple works somewhat like an open set of pallet forks with a hydraulic clamp above them.

Slide the lower tines underneath a pile of branches or logs, close the upper grapple, and the material rests on the lower structure while being held in place.

This can be particularly useful for crooked logs, forked branches, and uneven piles where several objects need support.

The compromise comes when repeatedly raking the ground. Some long-bottom designs need to be rotated farther forward to engage the tine tips at an effective working angle.

Short Rake Tines Engage Surface Debris

A short-bottom rake grapple generally has a more vertical working profile. The lower tines can gather loose roots, branches, and brush while the hydraulic upper clamp secures the material.

In a 2014 Heavy Equipment Forums discussion, Mobiltech described using a Stout grapple on his Cat 287B to rake near-surface roots and debris.

Skid steer owner k45 described the opposite problem with a long, curved-tine grapple rake:

“With the tines curved up at the end, I have to tilt is all the way down to pick up anything. That limits me to one or two logs/trees/whatever at a time. I can't go along and rake stuff up and close on it.”

k45, 2014, Heavy Equipment Forums.

That geometry can make repeated surface cleanup more convenient, although tine curvature and working angle still vary by model.

Can a Rake Grapple Carry Logs?

Yes. Rake grapples can handle logs when the attachment is suited to the size, weight, and shape of the load.

A straight log may clamp securely in a short clamshell grapple. Several crooked or tapered logs can be more difficult to hold evenly, especially with a single upper lid.

Compact tractor owners GrumpyFarmer and mikester discussed those differences in a 2024 OrangeTractorTalks discussion. Both preferred long-bottom twin-lid designs for carrying irregular bundles, although mikester found his previous clamshell effective for individual straight logs.

Root Grapple vs Brush Grapple: Different Attachment or Different Name?

Brush grapple usually describes what an attachment is intended to handle rather than one standardized shape.

Some brush grapples have long supporting lower tines. Others use shorter, rake-oriented tines and clamshell jaws.

For example, after clearing a fence line, you might have large piles of cut limbs and trunks mixed with smaller branches.

Junior M, who runs a long-tine Solesbee-style grapple on his skid steer, put the tradeoff simply:

“I wish I had more of a rake style because it's hard to rake with that style of grapple”

Junior M, 2015, LawnSite discussion.

For the large piles, long supporting lower tines can help carry more material in a stable bundle. For scattered branches and vines, rake geometry can make it easier to gather debris before clamping it.

The Storm Brush Grapple shows why the name alone isn't enough. The family includes 60 and 72 inch configurations with different weights, construction, and cylinder arrangements.

Its 60 inch single-cylinder SSQA version is currently listed at $2,052. Other configurations have different specifications and prices.

Don't shop for a brush grapple based on the word "brush." Compare the lower tines and upper clamp against the material you're actually moving.

Root Grapple vs Rock Grapple: What Stays Between the Tines?

One of the most frustrating things about buying a grapple with widely spaced tines is discovering that the debris you need to collect keeps falling through.

In a 2026 r/Skidsteer discussion, Background-Job-3629 described that exact problem with a rock bucket:

“Mine has the rock bucket but the tines are too far apart so I end up dropping rocks and running over them.”

Background-Job-3629, 2026, r/Skidsteer discussion.

The account concerns a rock bucket, not a root grapple. It illustrates why the spacing between tines deserves attention before buying either type.

Compare Actual Tine Spacing

Root vs rock grapple tine spacing infographic comparing Storm Root Grapple at 7 inches, Prime Root Grapple at 6.3 inches, Prime Rock and Brush Grapple at 3 inches, and Storm Rock Grapple at 2.75 inches

The Storm Root Grapple has 7 inch tine spacing, while the Storm Rock Grapple has 2.75 inch spacing.

The Prime Root Grapple has 6.3 inch spacing, while the Prime Rock and Brush Grapple has 3 inch spacing.

Wider spacing generally allows more small material to escape. Closer spacing helps retain smaller rocks and debris.

But don't assume a 3 inch opening guarantees collection of every 3 inch rock. The rock's smallest dimension, orientation, side openings, and gaps around the upper clamps can all affect whether it stays in the grapple.

Does Dirt Actually Fall Through?

Loose soil often passes through open tines, but the result changes with soil moisture and the material mixed into it.

Mobiltech said his wide-spaced Stout grapple let dirt pass through and that his rock bucket did not rake well. He warned that a close-spaced rock grapple could plug with dirt during the same kind of raking.

In that same discussion, Dustin described pine needles plugging rake tines and causing the attachment to retain more dirt.

Wet clay, compacted soil, roots, and organic debris can make separating dirt more difficult.

If your main job is gathering smaller rocks, closer tines may be worth the compromise. If you're clearing roots and large brush while leaving most of the dirt behind, wider spacing may be more useful.

Grapple Bucket vs Root Grapple: Should the Bottom Be Open or Solid?

Sometimes you need to pick up everything, including the small material an open-tine grapple would leave behind.

Demolition debris is a good example. Broken wood, smaller concrete fragments, dirt, and scraps can escape between widely spaced tines.

A solid-floor grapple bucket contains that material while its upper clamps secure larger objects.

But for land clearing, a solid floor can mean carrying dirt and rocks you would rather leave on the property.

Skid steer operator Bumpsteer described favoring an industrial grapple bucket in a 2014 Heavy Equipment Forums discussion. Besides collecting material, he valued being able to perform some ordinary bucket work without changing attachments.

There are three useful distinctions:

  • Open-tine grapple: Supports bulky debris while allowing some loose material to fall through.
  • Rock or skeleton grapple: Uses closer-spaced open tines to retain smaller objects while permitting some soil separation.
  • Solid-floor grapple bucket: Contains fine debris and soil along with larger material.

The Storm 60 Inch Grapple Bucket is one solid-floor example. The 60 inch SSQA configuration weighs 490 lb and is currently listed at $3,040.

Compare additional designs in our skid steer grapple attachments collection.

Single Lid or Independent Dual Clamps?

The upper grapple determines how material is held once the lower tines get underneath it.

A single full-width lid closes as one assembly. Two independently operating lids can close to different positions, helping them grip material of unequal thickness.

Why Independent Lids Help With Uneven Loads

Imagine carrying a large log that's considerably thicker at one end than the other.

With a single rigid lid, one part of the grapple may contact the thicker section before the opposite end is securely clamped.

Independent upper grapples can adapt to that difference.

In 2014, skid steer operator Skid Shear described modifying his grapple rake so the upper clamps worked separately:

“makes a world of difference when lifting loads that are not uniform from side to side.”

Skid Shear, 2014, Heavy Equipment Forums.

The Prime Root Grapple explicitly features two independently operating upper grapples.

Why Some Operators Still Prefer a Single Lid

For large brush piles and frequent raking, a continuous upper clamp can have advantages of its own.

In a 2025 r/Skidsteer discussion, OhhNooThatSucks preferred a nonsplit lid partly because he occasionally backdragged with the teeth and didn't want a gap in the upper assembly.

Whether backdragging is permitted depends on the specific attachment manufacturer's instructions.

Two Cylinders Aren't Necessarily Two Independent Lids

Some grapples use two hydraulic cylinders to operate one upper assembly. Others have two separate jaws capable of closing independently.

For example, the Storm Root Grapple offers one-cylinder and two-cylinder configurations, but that selector alone doesn't establish independent upper jaws.

Check the actual lid construction and hydraulic arrangement when independent clamping matters to your work.

Will a Root Grapple Pull Stumps Out of the Ground?

A root grapple can handle exposed roots, loosened stumps, and root balls within the attachment and loader's operating limits.

In the 2014 HEF thread, Mobiltech described using his 287B-mounted grapple to pull trees and get under roots.

In a 2011 TractorByNet discussion, deere5105 said his Bobcat S250 and 72 inch root grapple could get under a tree root ball and pop it up without losing the dirt. He separately described using the grapple to sift soil.

In a 2020 TractorByNet discussion, GeeVee described how his 48 inch Millonzi root rake on an ASV RC-30 engaged roots across more width than he wanted during selective clearing.

That made it difficult to work around established trees he wanted to preserve.

Carrying a freed root ball is different from excavating a deeply anchored stump. For substantial stump excavation, compare purpose-built attachments such as the skid steer stump buckets available at Yard Patriots.

Grapple Weight, Durability, and Machine Fit

A grapple needs enough strength for the work without consuming so much of the machine's lifting capability that you can't carry a useful load.

That balance matters on both smaller skid steers and large compact track loaders.

In a 2025 r/Skidsteer discussion, Deere 333G owner ktmfan described the carrying penalty directly. He liked his heavy grapple's construction but noted that its weight became a disadvantage when lifting a large tree with an attached root ball.

Attachment weight is only one consideration. How far forward the load sits, the machine's lift geometry, terrain, and operating limits also affect what can be handled safely.

Pay Attention to Hydraulic Protection

Brush piles can be hard on exposed hoses, fittings, and cylinders.

Branches can catch hydraulic lines or damage cylinder guards even when the grapple frame itself is holding up well.

Skid steer operator fastowl76, who described hundreds of hours using a root grapple on a Bobcat S650, emphasized that problem:

“The main thing on root grapples IMO is how well the hoses are protected as well as the rams.”

fastowl76, 2025, r/Skidsteer discussion.

Inspect the attachment's hose routing, cylinder protection, pivot construction, tine reinforcements, and serviceable wear components.

Is a Wider Grapple Better?

Not if it keeps you from reaching the material you're trying to move.

In a 2025 skid steer discussion, Scary-Shopping-8341 explained that a narrower grapple allowed access between standing trees where a wider attachment wouldn't fit.

Other operators favor a grapple approximately as wide as their skid steer for broader gathering and carrying work.

Choose based on the access available, the typical load, the attachment's operating weight, and the machine's capabilities. Engine horsepower alone isn't a reliable grapple-sizing chart.

Mini Skid Steers: Mounting and Weight Come First

Mini skid steers need particular attention to attachment weight, overall width, and mounting compatibility.

The Storm 48 Inch Rake Grapple offers separate mounting configurations including Skid Steer Quick Attach, Bobcat MT, and mini universal mounts.

Those mounting systems are not automatically interchangeable.

In a 2024 follow-up to his 2023 r/Skidsteer thread, Toro Dingo TX427 owner Far-Tomatillo451 said he bought a 34 inch Toro-style Titan root grapple and had to warranty “a few fittings.”

Compare mounting configurations in our mini skid steer grapple collection.

Compact Tractors Have Different Loader Limits

Compact tractor owners face similar decisions about grapple geometry, but their loaders, lift ratings, and ballast requirements are different.

In a 2018 OrangeTractorTalks discussion, crmorse described wishing his grapple were narrower when working around trees he wanted to preserve.

A grapple suitable for a large compact track loader is not automatically appropriate for a compact tractor.

Browse our tractor grapple collection for tractor-oriented configurations.

For either machine type, follow the carrier and attachment manuals for rated loads, approved raking or backdragging operations, hydraulic compatibility, guarding, and transport procedures.

Root Grapple vs Rake Grapple FAQ

Can a rake grapple carry logs?

Yes, especially single straight logs, but several crooked or tapered logs are harder to hold with a short, single-lid rake. See Can a Rake Grapple Carry Logs?

Can a root grapple pull stumps?

It can lift exposed roots, loosened stumps and root balls within the loader's limits, but it isn't a stump excavator. For embedded stumps, use a stump bucket and see the stump removal discussion.

What tine spacing do I need for rocks?

Root grapples like the Storm (7 in) and Prime (6.3 in) let smaller rocks fall through, while rock grapples such as the Storm (2.75 in) and Prime (3 in) hold onto more. See Root Grapple vs Rock Grapple.

Single lid or independent clamps?

Independent clamps grip uneven loads better, and a single full-width lid gives continuous contact for brush and raking. See Single Lid or Independent Dual Clamps?

Compare Root and Rake Grapples at Yard Patriots

These five models illustrate the differences in geometry, weight, and intended work. Each price refers to the specific configuration listed.

Model and Price Selected Configuration and Specifications
Storm Root Grapple

$1,667

48 inch, single cylinder, SSQA.

7 inch tine spacing. Long-bottom design for brush, logs, and roots.

Prime Root Grapple

$3,200

68 inch, 900 lb.

6.3 inch tine spacing, 39 inch opening, two independent upper grapples.

Storm Rake Grapple

$1,824

48 inch, SSQA.

32 inch opening, 3 inch minimum closing clearance, full-width upper clamp.

Glacier Extreme Duty Rake Grapple

$4,941

72 inch, SSQA.

5/8 inch tines, 52 inch opening. Attachment weight requires confirmation.

Storm Rock Grapple

$1,976

48 inch, single cylinder, SSQA.

2.75 inch tine spacing for retaining smaller rocks and debris.

These are currently listed product prices as of publishing, excluding freight, tax, and optional equipment.

Find the Right Grapple for Your Skid Steer

Compare our skid steer root grapples and grapple attachments to find the right design for your property or jobsite.

Call or text 833-405-1700 with your machine model and the material you're handling. We'll help you narrow down the options.

Previous article Flail Mower vs Brush Hog: Which Should You Buy?
Next article Snow Pusher vs Bucket for Skid Steers: Which Should You Use?